Prooflytics vs WhatConverts: Marketing Intelligence vs Lead and Call Tracking

Prooflytics vs WhatConverts: Marketing Intelligence vs Lead and Call Tracking

WhatConverts and Prooflytics address different gaps in marketing attribution. WhatConverts specializes in offline conversion tracking - matching phone calls, form submissions, and chat leads back to the specific ad, keyword, or campaign that generated them. Prooflytics monitors full paid channel performance with daily AI briefings, creative lifecycle classification, and a ranked action queue. For teams running phone-heavy or service businesses, both tools address real blind spots.

Quick verdict: Choose WhatConverts if call tracking and lead-source attribution are your primary gap - especially for service businesses where the conversion is a phone call. Choose Prooflytics if you need daily cross-channel intelligence with lifecycle scoring, HADI experiments, and action recommendations across Meta, Google, GA4, and LinkedIn.

Key takeaways

WhatConverts Closes the Offline Attribution Gap by Matching Calls and Forms to Specific Ads

WhatConverts matches phone calls, form submissions, and chat leads to the specific ad, campaign, and keyword that generated them. This closes an attribution gap that purely digital tracking cannot address - particularly for service businesses where the conversion is a phone call.

WhatConverts Starts at Thirty Dollars Per Month for One Tracking Number

The platform scales to $160 per month for unlimited tracking numbers and agency white-label. Prooflytics starts at $79 per month with all channels and AI intelligence included - the two tools address different attribution gaps and serve different primary use cases.

WhatConverts Is Essential for Phone-Heavy Service Businesses and Complementary to Prooflytics

WhatConverts solves a problem Prooflytics does not address - offline conversion tracking. The tools are complementary rather than competing, each solving a different attribution layer for the same team.

Choose WhatConverts for Call Tracking and Choose Prooflytics for Daily Cross-Channel Intelligence

If call tracking and lead-source attribution for phone-heavy or service businesses is the primary gap, WhatConverts is purpose-built for it. If daily cross-channel intelligence with lifecycle scoring, HADI, and action recommendations is the primary need, Prooflytics addresses that.

Meta Ads Lifecycle Scoring HADI and Competitor Intelligence Are Not Available in WhatConverts

These capabilities are included in every Prooflytics paid tier. WhatConverts is an attribution tool for offline conversions; the operational intelligence layer that covers creative lifecycle, hypothesis tracking, and competitor monitoring requires a different product.

What is WhatConverts?

WhatConverts: a lead tracking and call attribution platform that matches phone calls, form submissions, chat conversations, and transactions to the ad source, campaign, and keyword that generated them. Plans start at $30/mo (1 tracking number, basic reports) through $100/mo Pro (10 numbers, advanced attribution, CRM integrations) and $160/mo Agency (unlimited numbers, white-label, client portals). Enterprise pricing is custom.

WhatConverts closes the offline conversion gap - it answers "which ad generated this phone call?" It does not monitor overall campaign health, classify creative lifecycle stages, or recommend what to pause or scale.

What is Prooflytics?

Prooflytics: a marketing intelligence platform connecting Meta Ads, Google Ads, GA4, LinkedIn Ads, and 400+ other sources, delivering a daily AI briefing with lifecycle classification (Scaling / Mature / Fatiguing / Dead), cross-channel attribution reconciliation, HADI hypothesis tracking, Competitor Intelligence, and a ranked action queue with one-click apply.

Prooflytics

See what a marketing-intelligence layer changes

One brief across every source — and the memory of what works.

Start free trialSee pricing

14 days free · no credit card

How they compare

Pricing comparison

Prooflytics tier features:

• Starter $79/mo: 1 user, 5 accounts, weekly report, action queue, HADI, Competitor Intel, custom AI rules
• Growth $199/mo: 3 users, 15 accounts, + daily AI briefing, PDF/email, 10 tracked competitors
• Scale $449/mo: 10 users, 35 accounts, + monthly strategic report, API access, onboarding session
• Enterprise: Custom - unlimited everything, white-label PDF

The single-channel attribution gap

The ICP problem with call-tracking-only tools: WhatConverts is excellent at answering "which keyword generated this call." It does not answer "which creatives across all channels are entering fatigue," "how has Meta ROAS trended this week versus the previous month," or "what should be paused or scaled this morning." For businesses where phone calls are the primary conversion, WhatConverts fills a critical hole. For teams running full-funnel paid campaigns across Meta, Google, and LinkedIn, that hole is only one of several.

Prooflytics at $79-449/mo addresses the campaign-wide intelligence gap: daily briefings, lifecycle scores across all creatives, cross-channel attribution, and an action queue that tells you what to do - not just what happened. For service businesses running Google call-only campaigns, WhatConverts + Prooflytics covers both layers: offline attribution and daily campaign intelligence.

When WhatConverts is the right choice

• You run a service business where phone calls are the primary conversion event
• You need to match specific calls and form submissions to ads, keywords, and campaigns
• Call tracking, lead scoring, and CRM routing are core requirements
• You operate in local services, legal, medical, real estate, or other phone-driven verticals

When Prooflytics is the right choice

• You need daily cross-channel intelligence across Meta, Google, GA4, and LinkedIn
• Creative lifecycle scoring, HADI experiment tracking, and Competitor Intelligence are required
• You want an action queue that recommends what to pause, scale, or test each morning
• Your conversion events are digital (purchases, sign-ups, leads via form) rather than primarily phone calls

Bottom line

• WhatConverts is the right tool for businesses where offline conversions (calls, forms) need to be attributed back to specific ads and keywords.
• Prooflytics is daily campaign intelligence: lifecycle scores, anomaly alerts, HADI experiments, Competitor Intelligence, and a ranked action queue.
• For service businesses running paid campaigns, both tools solve real and different attribution gaps.

You can read independent reviews of Prooflytics on G2 and compare it to alternatives in the marketing analytics category.

Start a 14-day free trial and get your first daily briefing tomorrow. Or book a demo to see it on a live account.